[[!comment format=mdwn username="joey" subject="""comment 3""" date="2017-09-26T19:16:29Z" content=""" Hmm, if the file was not already in the index, that could be taken to indicate it was deleted/moved and replaced, rather than being modified, and so don't copy the metadata. But that would make these two sequences have different behavior: git rm file; echo foo > file; git annex add file echo foo > file; git annex add file As well as these two sequences: git mv file other; echo foo > file; git annex add file cp file other; echo foo > file; git annex add file other """]]