From fe09bfcc7fab6148e9aed9fb570f74494dad9fb6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: jadep <jade.philipoom@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, 12 Nov 2017 23:24:57 -0500
Subject: update to graph generation

---
 measurements/2017-11-03/table.tex | 737 ++++++++++++++++++--------------------
 1 file changed, 345 insertions(+), 392 deletions(-)

(limited to 'measurements/2017-11-03')

diff --git a/measurements/2017-11-03/table.tex b/measurements/2017-11-03/table.tex
index aaa673a6b..7d7541e59 100644
--- a/measurements/2017-11-03/table.tex
+++ b/measurements/2017-11-03/table.tex
@@ -1,405 +1,358 @@
 
-    \begin{figure*}
-    \begin{tikzpicture}
-    	\begin{axis}[
-    		height=11cm,
-    		width=\textwidth,
-    		grid=major,
-    		legend pos= north west,
-    		xlabel=Prime Size (bits),
-    		ylabel=Time (seconds)]
-    		\addplot[color=blue,mark=triangle*] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.12) 
-			(129, 0.19) 
-			(137, 0.20) 
-			(140, 0.20) 
-			(141, 0.20) 
-			(150, 0.20) 
-			(152, 0.19) 
-			(158, 0.20) 
-			(171, 0.28) 
-			(174, 0.28) 
-			(189, 0.28) 
-			(190, 0.29) 
-			(191, 0.28) 
-			(192, 0.27) 
-			(205, 0.36) 
-			(206, 0.37) 
-			(212, 0.38) 
-			(213, 0.37) 
-			(216, 0.38) 
-			(221, 0.38) 
-			(222, 0.37) 
-			(224, 0.32) 
+ \begin{figure*}
+ \begin{tikzpicture}
+ 	\begin{axis}[
+ 		height=9cm,
+ 		width=\textwidth,
+ 		legend pos= north west,
+ 		xtick distance=100,
+ 		extra x ticks={130,255,448,480},
+ 		extra x tick style={grid=major, tick label style={rotate=45,anchor=east}},
+ 		extra x tick labels={poly1305,curve25519/p256,goldilocks,ridinghood},
+ 		xlabel=log2(prime),
+ 		ylabel=Time (seconds)]		\addplot[color=blue,mark=square*] coordinates {
+			(127.0, 0.04) 
+			(129.0, 0.08) 
+			(137.0, 0.09) 
+			(140.0, 0.08) 
+			(141.0, 0.08) 
+			(150.0, 0.08) 
+			(152.0, 0.09) 
+			(158.0, 0.08) 
+			(165.0, 0.08) 
+			(166.0, 0.08) 
+			(171.0, 0.08) 
+			(174.0, 0.08) 
+			(189.0, 0.08) 
+			(190.0, 0.08) 
+			(191.0, 0.08) 
+			(192.0, 0.08) 
+			(204.37503943134692, 0.13) 
+			(206.0, 0.13) 
+			(212.0, 0.13) 
+			(213.0, 0.13) 
+			(216.0, 0.12) 
+			(221.0, 0.13) 
+			(222.0, 0.13) 
+			(224.0, 0.12) 
+			(226.0, 0.12) 
+			(230.0, 0.13) 
+			(235.0, 0.13) 
+			(243.0, 0.12) 
+			(251.0, 0.13) 
+			(253.98877343250717, 0.13) 
+			(255.0, 0.13) 
+			(256.0, 0.13) 
+			(255.99999999966408, 0.11) 
+			(255.9980614856364, 0.12) 
+			(266.0, 0.18) 
+			(285.0, 0.19) 
+			(291.0, 0.19) 
+			(321.0, 0.25) 
+			(336.0, 0.25) 
+			(338.0, 0.27) 
+			(369.0, 0.27) 
+			(379.0, 0.28) 
+			(382.0, 0.27) 
+			(383.0, 0.27) 
+			(384.0, 0.26) 
+			(383.9998899269044, 0.23) 
+			(383.467605550083, 0.23) 
+			(401.0, 0.35) 
+			(414.0, 0.35) 
+			(416.0, 0.35) 
+			(444.0, 0.35) 
+			(448.0, 0.32) 
 		};
-		\addlegendentry{fiat\_montgomery32}
-
-		\addplot[color=blue,mark=square*] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.04) 
-			(129, 0.08) 
-			(137, 0.09) 
-			(140, 0.08) 
-			(141, 0.08) 
-			(150, 0.08) 
-			(152, 0.09) 
-			(158, 0.08) 
-			(165, 0.08) 
-			(166, 0.08) 
-			(171, 0.08) 
-			(174, 0.08) 
-			(189, 0.08) 
-			(190, 0.08) 
-			(191, 0.08) 
-			(192, 0.08) 
-			(205, 0.13) 
-			(206, 0.13) 
-			(212, 0.13) 
-			(213, 0.13) 
-			(216, 0.12) 
-			(221, 0.13) 
-			(222, 0.13) 
-			(224, 0.12) 
-			(226, 0.12) 
-			(230, 0.13) 
-			(235, 0.13) 
-			(243, 0.12) 
-			(251, 0.13) 
-			(254, 0.13) 
-			(255, 0.13) 
-			(256, 0.13) 
-			(266, 0.18) 
-			(285, 0.19) 
-			(291, 0.19) 
-			(321, 0.25) 
-			(336, 0.25) 
-			(338, 0.27) 
-			(369, 0.27) 
-			(379, 0.28) 
-			(382, 0.27) 
-			(383, 0.27) 
-			(384, 0.26) 
-			(401, 0.35) 
-			(414, 0.35) 
-			(416, 0.35) 
-			(444, 0.35) 
-			(448, 0.32) 
-		};
-		\addlegendentry{fiat\_montgomery64}
-
-		\addplot[color=blue,mark=triangle] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.05) 
-			(129, 0.06) 
-			(130, 0.03) 
-			(137, 0.11) 
-			(140, 0.06) 
-			(141, 0.06) 
-			(150, 0.06) 
-			(152, 0.06) 
-			(158, 0.06) 
-			(165, 0.11) 
-			(166, 0.16) 
-			(171, 0.12) 
-			(174, 0.12) 
-			(191, 0.15) 
-			(194, 0.09) 
-			(198, 0.11) 
-			(206, 0.19) 
-			(213, 0.28) 
-			(216, 0.08) 
-			(221, 0.13) 
-			(222, 0.13) 
-			(230, 0.13) 
-			(235, 0.10) 
-			(243, 0.10) 
-			(251, 0.13) 
-			(255, 0.13) 
-			(256, 0.18) 
-			(266, 0.19) 
-			(285, 0.27) 
-			(291, 0.18) 
-			(321, 0.30) 
-			(322, 0.21) 
-			(336, 0.23) 
-			(338, 0.20) 
-			(369, 0.29) 
-			(401, 0.30) 
-			(416, 0.25) 
-		};
-		\addlegendentry{fiat\_solinas32}
+		\addlegendentry{ours, Montgomery reduction}
 
 		\addplot[color=blue,mark=square] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.02) 
-			(129, 0.03) 
-			(130, 0.03) 
-			(137, 0.05) 
-			(140, 0.04) 
-			(141, 0.03) 
-			(150, 0.03) 
-			(152, 0.04) 
-			(158, 0.04) 
-			(165, 0.03) 
-			(166, 0.03) 
-			(171, 0.03) 
-			(174, 0.03) 
-			(189, 0.04) 
-			(190, 0.04) 
-			(191, 0.07) 
-			(192, 0.05) 
-			(194, 0.04) 
-			(196, 0.04) 
-			(198, 0.04) 
-			(206, 0.04) 
-			(212, 0.05) 
-			(213, 0.04) 
-			(216, 0.04) 
-			(221, 0.04) 
-			(222, 0.05) 
-			(226, 0.04) 
-			(230, 0.05) 
-			(235, 0.07) 
-			(243, 0.10) 
-			(251, 0.06) 
-			(255, 0.06) 
-			(256, 0.06) 
-			(266, 0.06) 
-			(285, 0.06) 
-			(291, 0.07) 
-			(321, 0.10) 
-			(336, 0.10) 
-			(338, 0.10) 
-			(369, 0.15) 
-			(379, 0.13) 
-			(382, 0.23) 
-			(384, 0.15) 
-			(401, 0.15) 
-			(414, 0.20) 
-			(416, 0.12) 
-			(444, 0.16) 
-			(448, 0.12) 
-			(450, 0.12) 
-			(452, 0.16) 
-			(468, 0.17) 
-			(480, 0.15) 
-			(488, 0.55) 
-			(489, 0.20) 
-			(495, 0.19) 
-			(511, 0.24) 
-			(512, 0.24) 
-			(521, 0.25) 
+			(127.0, 0.02) 
+			(129.0, 0.03) 
+			(130.0, 0.03) 
+			(137.0, 0.05) 
+			(140.0, 0.04) 
+			(141.0, 0.03) 
+			(150.0, 0.03) 
+			(152.0, 0.04) 
+			(158.0, 0.04) 
+			(165.0, 0.03) 
+			(166.0, 0.03) 
+			(171.0, 0.03) 
+			(174.0, 0.03) 
+			(189.0, 0.04) 
+			(190.0, 0.04) 
+			(191.0, 0.07) 
+			(192.0, 0.05) 
+			(194.0, 0.04) 
+			(196.0, 0.04) 
+			(198.0, 0.04) 
+			(206.0, 0.04) 
+			(212.0, 0.05) 
+			(213.0, 0.04) 
+			(216.0, 0.04) 
+			(221.0, 0.04) 
+			(222.0, 0.05) 
+			(226.0, 0.04) 
+			(230.0, 0.05) 
+			(235.0, 0.07) 
+			(243.0, 0.10) 
+			(251.0, 0.06) 
+			(255.0, 0.06) 
+			(256.0, 0.06) 
+			(266.0, 0.06) 
+			(285.0, 0.06) 
+			(291.0, 0.07) 
+			(321.0, 0.10) 
+			(336.0, 0.10) 
+			(338.0, 0.10) 
+			(369.0, 0.15) 
+			(379.0, 0.13) 
+			(382.0, 0.23) 
+			(384.0, 0.15) 
+			(401.0, 0.15) 
+			(414.0, 0.20) 
+			(416.0, 0.12) 
+			(444.0, 0.16) 
+			(448.0, 0.12) 
+			(450.0, 0.12) 
+			(452.0, 0.16) 
+			(468.0, 0.17) 
+			(480.0, 0.15) 
+			(488.0, 0.55) 
+			(489.0, 0.20) 
+			(495.0, 0.19) 
+			(511.0, 0.24) 
+			(512.0, 0.24) 
+			(521.0, 0.25) 
 		};
-		\addlegendentry{fiat\_solinas64}
+		\addlegendentry{ours, Solinas reduction}
 
-		\addplot[color=red,mark=ball*] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.15) 
-			(129, 0.27) 
-			(130, 0.27) 
-			(137, 0.27) 
-			(140, 0.27) 
-			(141, 0.27) 
-			(150, 0.27) 
-			(152, 0.27) 
-			(158, 0.27) 
-			(165, 0.27) 
-			(166, 0.27) 
-			(171, 0.27) 
-			(174, 0.27) 
-			(189, 0.28) 
-			(190, 0.27) 
-			(191, 0.26) 
-			(192, 0.24) 
-			(194, 0.35) 
-			(196, 0.34) 
-			(198, 0.34) 
-			(205, 0.34) 
-			(206, 0.34) 
-			(212, 0.35) 
-			(213, 0.35) 
-			(216, 0.35) 
-			(221, 0.35) 
-			(222, 0.34) 
-			(224, 0.35) 
-			(226, 0.34) 
-			(230, 0.34) 
-			(235, 0.34) 
-			(243, 0.34) 
-			(251, 0.35) 
-			(254, 0.35) 
-			(255, 0.33) 
-			(256, 0.34) 
-			(266, 0.43) 
-			(285, 0.43) 
-			(291, 0.43) 
-			(321, 0.52) 
-			(322, 0.52) 
-			(336, 0.53) 
-			(338, 0.53) 
-			(369, 0.53) 
-			(379, 0.53) 
-			(382, 0.53) 
-			(383, 0.50) 
-			(384, 0.47) 
-			(389, 0.59) 
-			(401, 0.60) 
-			(413, 0.61) 
-			(414, 0.60) 
-			(416, 0.60) 
-			(444, 0.60) 
-			(448, 0.53) 
-			(450, 0.69) 
-			(452, 0.68) 
-			(468, 0.69) 
-			(480, 0.69) 
-			(488, 0.69) 
-			(489, 0.69) 
-			(495, 0.69) 
-			(510, 0.69) 
-			(511, 0.65) 
-			(512, 0.63) 
-			(521, 0.81) 
+		\addplot[color=red,mark=*] coordinates {
+			(127.0, 0.15) 
+			(129.0, 0.27) 
+			(130.0, 0.27) 
+			(137.0, 0.27) 
+			(140.0, 0.27) 
+			(141.0, 0.27) 
+			(150.0, 0.27) 
+			(152.0, 0.27) 
+			(158.0, 0.27) 
+			(165.0, 0.27) 
+			(166.0, 0.27) 
+			(171.0, 0.27) 
+			(174.0, 0.27) 
+			(189.0, 0.28) 
+			(190.0, 0.27) 
+			(191.0, 0.26) 
+			(192.0, 0.24) 
+			(194.0, 0.35) 
+			(196.0, 0.34) 
+			(198.0, 0.34) 
+			(204.37503943134692, 0.34) 
+			(206.0, 0.34) 
+			(212.0, 0.35) 
+			(213.0, 0.35) 
+			(216.0, 0.35) 
+			(221.0, 0.35) 
+			(222.0, 0.34) 
+			(224.0, 0.35) 
+			(226.0, 0.34) 
+			(230.0, 0.34) 
+			(235.0, 0.34) 
+			(243.0, 0.34) 
+			(251.0, 0.35) 
+			(253.98877343250717, 0.35) 
+			(255.0, 0.33) 
+			(256.0, 0.34) 
+			(255.99999999966408, 0.33) 
+			(255.9980614856364, 0.34) 
+			(266.0, 0.43) 
+			(285.0, 0.43) 
+			(291.0, 0.43) 
+			(321.0, 0.52) 
+			(322.0, 0.52) 
+			(336.0, 0.53) 
+			(338.0, 0.53) 
+			(369.0, 0.53) 
+			(379.0, 0.53) 
+			(382.0, 0.53) 
+			(383.0, 0.50) 
+			(384.0, 0.47) 
+			(383.9998899269044, 0.46) 
+			(383.467605550083, 0.46) 
+			(389.0, 0.59) 
+			(401.0, 0.60) 
+			(413.0, 0.61) 
+			(414.0, 0.60) 
+			(416.0, 0.60) 
+			(444.0, 0.60) 
+			(448.0, 0.53) 
+			(450.0, 0.69) 
+			(452.0, 0.68) 
+			(468.0, 0.69) 
+			(480.0, 0.69) 
+			(488.0, 0.69) 
+			(489.0, 0.69) 
+			(495.0, 0.69) 
+			(509.97423531735535, 0.69) 
+			(511.0, 0.65) 
+			(511.9891505409899, 0.63) 
+			(512.0, 0.62) 
+			(521.0, 0.81) 
 		};
-		\addlegendentry{gmpvar}
+		\addlegendentry{GMP mpn\_ API}
 
 		\addplot[color=red,mark=o] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.61) 
-			(129, 0.79) 
-			(130, 0.78) 
-			(137, 0.81) 
-			(140, 0.81) 
-			(141, 0.81) 
-			(150, 0.80) 
-			(152, 0.80) 
-			(158, 0.76) 
-			(165, 0.79) 
-			(166, 0.78) 
-			(171, 0.79) 
-			(174, 0.78) 
-			(189, 0.79) 
-			(190, 0.78) 
-			(191, 0.77) 
-			(192, 0.71) 
-			(194, 0.93) 
-			(196, 0.87) 
-			(198, 0.86) 
-			(205, 0.84) 
-			(206, 0.86) 
-			(212, 0.88) 
-			(213, 0.88) 
-			(216, 0.86) 
-			(221, 0.88) 
-			(222, 0.88) 
-			(224, 0.86) 
-			(226, 0.90) 
-			(230, 0.88) 
-			(235, 0.88) 
-			(243, 0.89) 
-			(251, 0.90) 
-			(254, 0.90) 
-			(255, 0.87) 
-			(256, 0.85) 
-			(266, 0.98) 
-			(285, 0.97) 
-			(291, 0.99) 
-			(321, 1.16) 
-			(322, 1.13) 
-			(336, 1.07) 
-			(338, 1.06) 
-			(369, 1.06) 
-			(379, 1.07) 
-			(382, 1.08) 
-			(383, 1.04) 
-			(384, 0.97) 
-			(389, 1.18) 
-			(401, 1.16) 
-			(413, 1.17) 
-			(414, 1.16) 
-			(416, 1.17) 
-			(444, 1.17) 
-			(448, 1.05) 
-			(450, 1.34) 
-			(452, 1.29) 
-			(468, 1.26) 
-			(480, 1.27) 
-			(488, 1.27) 
-			(489, 1.27) 
-			(495, 1.29) 
-			(510, 1.26) 
-			(511, 1.22) 
-			(512, 1.15) 
-			(521, 1.39) 
+			(127.0, 0.61) 
+			(129.0, 0.79) 
+			(130.0, 0.78) 
+			(137.0, 0.81) 
+			(140.0, 0.81) 
+			(141.0, 0.81) 
+			(150.0, 0.80) 
+			(152.0, 0.80) 
+			(158.0, 0.76) 
+			(165.0, 0.79) 
+			(166.0, 0.78) 
+			(171.0, 0.79) 
+			(174.0, 0.78) 
+			(189.0, 0.79) 
+			(190.0, 0.78) 
+			(191.0, 0.77) 
+			(192.0, 0.71) 
+			(194.0, 0.93) 
+			(196.0, 0.87) 
+			(198.0, 0.86) 
+			(204.37503943134692, 0.84) 
+			(206.0, 0.86) 
+			(212.0, 0.88) 
+			(213.0, 0.88) 
+			(216.0, 0.86) 
+			(221.0, 0.88) 
+			(222.0, 0.88) 
+			(224.0, 0.86) 
+			(226.0, 0.90) 
+			(230.0, 0.88) 
+			(235.0, 0.88) 
+			(243.0, 0.89) 
+			(251.0, 0.90) 
+			(253.98877343250717, 0.90) 
+			(255.0, 0.87) 
+			(256.0, 0.85) 
+			(255.99999999966408, 0.85) 
+			(255.9980614856364, 0.86) 
+			(266.0, 0.98) 
+			(285.0, 0.97) 
+			(291.0, 0.99) 
+			(321.0, 1.16) 
+			(322.0, 1.13) 
+			(336.0, 1.07) 
+			(338.0, 1.06) 
+			(369.0, 1.06) 
+			(379.0, 1.07) 
+			(382.0, 1.08) 
+			(383.0, 1.04) 
+			(384.0, 0.97) 
+			(383.9998899269044, 0.97) 
+			(383.467605550083, 0.96) 
+			(389.0, 1.18) 
+			(401.0, 1.16) 
+			(413.0, 1.17) 
+			(414.0, 1.16) 
+			(416.0, 1.17) 
+			(444.0, 1.17) 
+			(448.0, 1.05) 
+			(450.0, 1.34) 
+			(452.0, 1.29) 
+			(468.0, 1.26) 
+			(480.0, 1.27) 
+			(488.0, 1.27) 
+			(489.0, 1.27) 
+			(495.0, 1.29) 
+			(509.97423531735535, 1.26) 
+			(511.0, 1.22) 
+			(511.9891505409899, 1.15) 
+			(512.0, 1.14) 
+			(521.0, 1.39) 
 		};
-		\addlegendentry{gmpxx}
+		\addlegendentry{GMP C++ API}
 
-		\addplot[color=red,mark=*] coordinates {
-			(127, 0.27) 
-			(129, 0.38) 
-			(130, 0.38) 
-			(137, 0.38) 
-			(140, 0.38) 
-			(141, 0.38) 
-			(150, 0.38) 
-			(152, 0.38) 
-			(158, 0.38) 
-			(165, 0.38) 
-			(166, 0.38) 
-			(171, 0.38) 
-			(174, 0.38) 
-			(189, 0.38) 
-			(190, 0.38) 
-			(191, 0.36) 
-			(192, 0.28) 
-			(194, 0.50) 
-			(196, 0.50) 
-			(198, 0.50) 
-			(205, 0.49) 
-			(206, 0.50) 
-			(212, 0.50) 
-			(213, 0.50) 
-			(216, 0.50) 
-			(221, 0.50) 
-			(222, 0.50) 
-			(224, 0.50) 
-			(226, 0.50) 
-			(230, 0.49) 
-			(235, 0.50) 
-			(243, 0.50) 
-			(251, 0.50) 
-			(254, 0.50) 
-			(255, 0.48) 
-			(256, 0.38) 
-			(266, 0.64) 
-			(285, 0.65) 
-			(291, 0.64) 
-			(321, 0.80) 
-			(322, 0.81) 
-			(336, 0.80) 
-			(338, 0.79) 
-			(369, 0.79) 
-			(379, 0.80) 
-			(382, 0.81) 
-			(383, 0.75) 
-			(384, 0.63) 
-			(389, 0.96) 
-			(401, 0.97) 
-			(413, 0.97) 
-			(414, 0.96) 
-			(416, 0.96) 
-			(444, 0.96) 
-			(448, 0.77) 
-			(450, 1.17) 
-			(452, 1.17) 
-			(468, 1.17) 
-			(480, 1.17) 
-			(488, 1.16) 
-			(489, 1.17) 
-			(495, 1.16) 
-			(510, 1.17) 
-			(511, 1.11) 
-			(512, 0.95) 
-			(521, 1.41) 
+		\addplot[color=red,mark=x] coordinates {
+			(127.0, 0.27) 
+			(129.0, 0.38) 
+			(130.0, 0.38) 
+			(137.0, 0.38) 
+			(140.0, 0.38) 
+			(141.0, 0.38) 
+			(150.0, 0.38) 
+			(152.0, 0.38) 
+			(158.0, 0.38) 
+			(165.0, 0.38) 
+			(166.0, 0.38) 
+			(171.0, 0.38) 
+			(174.0, 0.38) 
+			(189.0, 0.38) 
+			(190.0, 0.38) 
+			(191.0, 0.36) 
+			(192.0, 0.28) 
+			(194.0, 0.50) 
+			(196.0, 0.50) 
+			(198.0, 0.50) 
+			(204.37503943134692, 0.49) 
+			(206.0, 0.50) 
+			(212.0, 0.50) 
+			(213.0, 0.50) 
+			(216.0, 0.50) 
+			(221.0, 0.50) 
+			(222.0, 0.50) 
+			(224.0, 0.50) 
+			(226.0, 0.50) 
+			(230.0, 0.49) 
+			(235.0, 0.50) 
+			(243.0, 0.50) 
+			(251.0, 0.50) 
+			(253.98877343250717, 0.50) 
+			(255.0, 0.48) 
+			(256.0, 0.38) 
+			(255.99999999966408, 0.37) 
+			(255.9980614856364, 0.37) 
+			(266.0, 0.64) 
+			(285.0, 0.65) 
+			(291.0, 0.64) 
+			(321.0, 0.80) 
+			(322.0, 0.81) 
+			(336.0, 0.80) 
+			(338.0, 0.79) 
+			(369.0, 0.79) 
+			(379.0, 0.80) 
+			(382.0, 0.81) 
+			(383.0, 0.75) 
+			(384.0, 0.63) 
+			(383.9998899269044, 0.62) 
+			(383.467605550083, 0.62) 
+			(389.0, 0.96) 
+			(401.0, 0.97) 
+			(413.0, 0.97) 
+			(414.0, 0.96) 
+			(416.0, 0.96) 
+			(444.0, 0.96) 
+			(448.0, 0.77) 
+			(450.0, 1.17) 
+			(452.0, 1.17) 
+			(468.0, 1.17) 
+			(480.0, 1.17) 
+			(488.0, 1.16) 
+			(489.0, 1.17) 
+			(495.0, 1.16) 
+			(509.97423531735535, 1.17) 
+			(511.0, 1.11) 
+			(511.9891505409899, 0.95) 
+			(512.0, 0.96) 
+			(521.0, 1.41) 
 		};
-		\addlegendentry{gmpsec}
-
+		\addlegendentry{GMP mpn\_sec API}
 
-    	\end{axis}
-    \end{figure*}
-    
+	\end{axis}
+\end{tikzpicture}
+\end{figure*}
-- 
cgit v1.2.3