(************************************************************************) (* v * The Coq Proof Assistant / The Coq Development Team *) (* R. (*********) Boxed Fixpoint Rmax_N (N:nat) : R := match N with | O => Un 0 | S n => Rmax (Un (S n)) (Rmax_N n) end. (*********) Definition EUn r : Prop := exists i : nat, r = Un i. (*********) Definition Un_cv (l:R) : Prop := forall eps:R, eps > 0 -> exists N : nat, (forall n:nat, (n >= N)%nat -> R_dist (Un n) l < eps). (*********) Definition Cauchy_crit : Prop := forall eps:R, eps > 0 -> exists N : nat, (forall n m:nat, (n >= N)%nat -> (m >= N)%nat -> R_dist (Un n) (Un m) < eps). (*********) Definition Un_growing : Prop := forall n:nat, Un n <= Un (S n). (*********) Lemma EUn_noempty : exists r : R, EUn r. unfold EUn in |- *; split with (Un 0); split with 0%nat; trivial. Qed. (*********) Lemma Un_in_EUn : forall n:nat, EUn (Un n). intro; unfold EUn in |- *; split with n; trivial. Qed. (*********) Lemma Un_bound_imp : forall x:R, (forall n:nat, Un n <= x) -> is_upper_bound EUn x. intros; unfold is_upper_bound in |- *; intros; unfold EUn in H0; elim H0; clear H0; intros; generalize (H x1); intro; rewrite <- H0 in H1; trivial. Qed. (*********) Lemma growing_prop : forall n m:nat, Un_growing -> (n >= m)%nat -> Un n >= Un m. double induction n m; intros. unfold Rge in |- *; right; trivial. elimtype False; unfold ge in H1; generalize (le_Sn_O n0); intro; auto. cut (n0 >= 0)%nat. generalize H0; intros; unfold Un_growing in H0; apply (Rge_trans (Un (S n0)) (Un n0) (Un 0) (Rle_ge (Un n0) (Un (S n0)) (H0 n0)) (H 0%nat H2 H3)). elim n0; auto. elim (lt_eq_lt_dec n1 n0); intro y. elim y; clear y; intro y. unfold ge in H2; generalize (le_not_lt n0 n1 (le_S_n n0 n1 H2)); intro; elimtype False; auto. rewrite y; unfold Rge in |- *; right; trivial. unfold ge in H0; generalize (H0 (S n0) H1 (lt_le_S n0 n1 y)); intro; unfold Un_growing in H1; apply (Rge_trans (Un (S n1)) (Un n1) (Un (S n0)) (Rle_ge (Un n1) (Un (S n1)) (H1 n1)) H3). Qed. (* classical is needed: [not_all_not_ex] *) (*********) Lemma Un_cv_crit : Un_growing -> bound EUn -> exists l : R, Un_cv l. unfold Un_growing, Un_cv in |- *; intros; generalize (completeness_weak EUn H0 EUn_noempty); intro; elim H1; clear H1; intros; split with x; intros; unfold is_lub in H1; unfold bound in H0; unfold is_upper_bound in H0, H1; elim H0; clear H0; intros; elim H1; clear H1; intros; generalize (H3 x0 H0); intro; cut (forall n:nat, Un n <= x); intro. cut (exists N : nat, x - eps < Un N). intro; elim H6; clear H6; intros; split with x1. intros; unfold R_dist in |- *; apply (Rabs_def1 (Un n - x) eps). unfold Rgt in H2; apply (Rle_lt_trans (Un n - x) 0 eps (Rle_minus (Un n) x (H5 n)) H2). fold Un_growing in H; generalize (growing_prop n x1 H H7); intro; generalize (Rlt_le_trans (x - eps) (Un x1) (Un n) H6 (Rge_le (Un n) (Un x1) H8)); intro; generalize (Rplus_lt_compat_l (- x) (x - eps) (Un n) H9); unfold Rminus in |- *; rewrite <- (Rplus_assoc (- x) x (- eps)); rewrite (Rplus_comm (- x) (Un n)); fold (Un n - x) in |- *; rewrite Rplus_opp_l; rewrite (let (H1, H2) := Rplus_ne (- eps) in H2); trivial. cut (~ (forall N:nat, x - eps >= Un N)). intro; apply (not_all_not_ex nat (fun N:nat => x - eps < Un N)); red in |- *; intro; red in H6; elim H6; clear H6; intro; apply (Rnot_lt_ge (x - eps) (Un N) (H7 N)). red in |- *; intro; cut (forall N:nat, Un N <= x - eps). intro; generalize (Un_bound_imp (x - eps) H7); intro; unfold is_upper_bound in H8; generalize (H3 (x - eps) H8); intro; generalize (Rle_minus x (x - eps) H9); unfold Rminus in |- *; rewrite Ropp_plus_distr; rewrite <- Rplus_assoc; rewrite Rplus_opp_r; rewrite (let (H1, H2) := Rplus_ne (- - eps) in H2); rewrite Ropp_involutive; intro; unfold Rgt in H2; generalize (Rgt_not_le eps 0 H2); intro; auto. intro; elim (H6 N); intro; unfold Rle in |- *. left; unfold Rgt in H7; assumption. right; auto. apply (H1 (Un n) (Un_in_EUn n)). Qed. (*********) Lemma finite_greater : forall N:nat, exists M : R, (forall n:nat, (n <= N)%nat -> Un n <= M). intro; induction N as [| N HrecN]. split with (Un 0); intros; rewrite (le_n_O_eq n H); apply (Req_le (Un n) (Un n) (refl_equal (Un n))). elim HrecN; clear HrecN; intros; split with (Rmax (Un (S N)) x); intros; elim (Rmax_Rle (Un (S N)) x (Un n)); intros; clear H1; inversion H0. rewrite <- H1; rewrite <- H1 in H2; apply (H2 (or_introl (Un n <= x) (Req_le (Un n) (Un n) (refl_equal (Un n))))). apply (H2 (or_intror (Un n <= Un (S N)) (H n H3))). Qed. (*********) Lemma cauchy_bound : Cauchy_crit -> bound EUn. unfold Cauchy_crit, bound in |- *; intros; unfold is_upper_bound in |- *; unfold Rgt in H; elim (H 1 Rlt_0_1); clear H; intros; generalize (H x); intro; generalize (le_dec x); intro; elim (finite_greater x); intros; split with (Rmax x0 (Un x + 1)); clear H; intros; unfold EUn in H; elim H; clear H; intros; elim (H1 x2); clear H1; intro y. unfold ge in H0; generalize (H0 x2 (le_n x) y); clear H0; intro; rewrite <- H in H0; unfold R_dist in H0; elim (Rabs_def2 (Un x - x1) 1 H0); clear H0; intros; elim (Rmax_Rle x0 (Un x + 1) x1); intros; apply H4; clear H3 H4; right; clear H H0 y; apply (Rlt_le x1 (Un x + 1)); generalize (Rlt_minus (-1) (Un x - x1) H1); clear H1; intro; apply (Rminus_lt x1 (Un x + 1)); cut (-1 - (Un x - x1) = x1 - (Un x + 1)); [ intro; rewrite H0 in H; assumption | ring ]. generalize (H2 x2 y); clear H2 H0; intro; rewrite <- H in H0; elim (Rmax_Rle x0 (Un x + 1) x1); intros; clear H1; apply H2; left; assumption. Qed. End sequence. (*****************************************************************) (* Definition of Power Series and properties *) (* *) (*****************************************************************) Section Isequence. (*********) Variable An : nat -> R. (*********) Definition Pser (x l:R) : Prop := infinit_sum (fun n:nat => An n * x ^ n) l. End Isequence. Lemma GP_infinite : forall x:R, Rabs x < 1 -> Pser (fun n:nat => 1) x (/ (1 - x)). intros; unfold Pser in |- *; unfold infinit_sum in |- *; intros; elim (Req_dec x 0). intros; exists 0%nat; intros; rewrite H1; rewrite Rminus_0_r; rewrite Rinv_1; cut (sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => 1 * 0 ^ n0) n = 1). intros; rewrite H3; rewrite R_dist_eq; auto. elim n; simpl in |- *. ring. intros; rewrite H3; ring. intro; cut (0 < eps * (Rabs (1 - x) * Rabs (/ x))). intro; elim (pow_lt_1_zero x H (eps * (Rabs (1 - x) * Rabs (/ x))) H2); intro N; intros; exists N; intros; cut (sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => 1 * x ^ n0) n = sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => x ^ n0) n). intros; rewrite H5; apply (Rmult_lt_reg_l (Rabs (1 - x)) (R_dist (sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => x ^ n0) n) (/ (1 - x))) eps). apply Rabs_pos_lt. apply Rminus_eq_contra. apply Rlt_dichotomy_converse. right; unfold Rgt in |- *. apply (Rle_lt_trans x (Rabs x) 1). apply RRle_abs. assumption. unfold R_dist in |- *; rewrite <- Rabs_mult. rewrite Rmult_minus_distr_l. cut ((1 - x) * sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => x ^ n0) n = - (sum_f_R0 (fun n0:nat => x ^ n0) n * (x - 1))). intro; rewrite H6. rewrite GP_finite. rewrite Rinv_r. cut (- (x ^ (n + 1) - 1) - 1 = - x ^ (n + 1)). intro; rewrite H7. rewrite Rabs_Ropp; cut ((n + 1)%nat = S n); auto. intro H8; rewrite H8; simpl in |- *; rewrite Rabs_mult; apply (Rlt_le_trans (Rabs x * Rabs (x ^ n)) (Rabs x * (eps * (Rabs (1 - x) * Rabs (/ x)))) ( Rabs (1 - x) * eps)). apply Rmult_lt_compat_l. apply Rabs_pos_lt. assumption. auto. cut (Rabs x * (eps * (Rabs (1 - x) * Rabs (/ x))) = Rabs x * Rabs (/ x) * (eps * Rabs (1 - x))). clear H8; intros; rewrite H8; rewrite <- Rabs_mult; rewrite Rinv_r. rewrite Rabs_R1; cut (1 * (eps * Rabs (1 - x)) = Rabs (1 - x) * eps). intros; rewrite H9; unfold Rle in |- *; right; reflexivity. ring. assumption. ring. ring. ring. apply Rminus_eq_contra. apply Rlt_dichotomy_converse. right; unfold Rgt in |- *. apply (Rle_lt_trans x (Rabs x) 1). apply RRle_abs. assumption. ring; ring. elim n; simpl in |- *. ring. intros; rewrite H5. ring. apply Rmult_lt_0_compat. auto. apply Rmult_lt_0_compat. apply Rabs_pos_lt. apply Rminus_eq_contra. apply Rlt_dichotomy_converse. right; unfold Rgt in |- *. apply (Rle_lt_trans x (Rabs x) 1). apply RRle_abs. assumption. apply Rabs_pos_lt. apply Rinv_neq_0_compat. assumption. Qed.