1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
|
(* $Id$ *)
open Pp
open Util
open Names
open Generic
open Term
open Sign
open Evd
open Printer
open Reduction
open Tacmach
open Proof_trees
open Clenv
open Declare
open Wcclausenv
open Pattern
open Tacticals
open Tactics
open Equality
open Inv
(* Fonctions temporaires pour relier la forme castée et la forme jugement *)
let tsign_of_csign (idl,tl) = (idl,List.map outcast_type tl)
let csign_of_tsign (idl,tl) = (idl,List.map incast_type tl)
(* FIN TMP *)
let not_work_message = "tactic fails to build the inversion lemma, may be because the predicate has arguments that depend on other arguments"
(* Inversion stored in lemmas *)
(* ALGORITHM:
An inversion stored in a lemma is computed from a term-pattern, in
a signature, as follows:
Suppose we have an inductive relation, (I abar), in a signature Gamma:
Gamma |- (I abar)
Then we compute the free-variables of abar. Suppose that Gamma is
thinned out to only include these.
[We need technically to require that all free-variables of the
types of the free variables of abar are themselves free-variables
of abar. This needs to be checked, but it should not pose a
problem - it is hard to imagine cases where it would not hold.]
Now, we pose the goal:
(P:(Gamma)Prop)(Gamma)(I abar)->(P vars[Gamma]).
We execute the tactic:
REPEAT Intro THEN (OnLastHyp (Inv NONE false o outSOME))
This leaves us with some subgoals. All the assumptions after "P"
in these subgoals are new assumptions. I.e. if we have a subgoal,
P:(Gamma)Prop, Gamma, Hbar:Tbar |- (P ybar)
then the assumption we needed to have was
(Hbar:Tbar)(P ybar)
So we construct all the assumptions we need, and rebuild the goal
with these assumptions. Then, we can re-apply the same tactic as
above, but instead of stopping after the inversion, we just apply
the respective assumption in each subgoal.
*)
let thin_hyps_to_term (hyps,t) =
let vars = (global_vars t) in
rev_sign(fst(it_sign (fun ((hyps,globs) as sofar) id a ->
if List.mem id globs then
(add_sign (id,a) hyps,(global_vars a)@globs)
else sofar) (nil_sign,vars) hyps))
(* returns the sub_signature of sign corresponding to those identifiers that
* are not global. *)
let get_local_sign sign =
let lid = ids_of_sign sign in
let globsign = initial_sign() in
let add_local id res_sign =
if not (mem_sign globsign id) then
add_sign (lookup_sign id sign) res_sign
else
res_sign
in
List.fold_right add_local lid nil_sign
(* returs the identifier of lid that was the latest declared in sign.
* (i.e. is the identifier id of lid such that
* sign_length (sign_prefix id sign) > sign_length (sign_prefix id' sign) >
* for any id'<>id in lid).
* it returns both the pair (id,(sign_prefix id sign)) *)
let max_prefix_sign lid sign =
let rec max_rec (resid,prefix) = function
| [] -> (resid,prefix)
| (id::l) ->
let pre = sign_prefix id sign in
if sign_length pre > sign_length prefix then
max_rec (id,pre) l
else
max_rec (resid,prefix) l
in
let (id::l) = lid in
max_rec (id, sign_prefix id sign) l
let rel_of_env env =
let rec rel_rec = function
| ([], _) -> []
| ((_::env), n) -> (Rel n)::(rel_rec (env, n+1))
in
rel_rec (env, 1)
let build_app op env = applist (op, List.rev (rel_of_env env))
(* similar to prod_and_pop, but gives [na:T]B intead of (na:T)B *)
let prod_and_pop_named = function
| ([], body, l, acc_ids) -> error "lam_and_pop"
| (((na,t)::tlenv), body, l, acc_ids) ->
let (Name id)=
if na=Anonymous then
Name(next_ident_away (id_of_string "a") acc_ids)
else
na
in
(tlenv,DOP2(Prod,t,DLAM((Name id),body)),
List.map (function
| (0,x) -> (0,lift (-1) x)
| (n,x) -> (n-1,x)) l,
(id::acc_ids))
(* similar to prod_and_popl but gives [nan:Tan]...[na1:Ta1]B instead of
* (nan:Tan)...(na1:Ta1)B it generates new names with respect to l
whenever nai=Anonymous *)
let prod_and_popl_named n env t l =
let rec poprec = function
| (0, (env,b,l,_)) -> (env,b,l)
| (n, ([],_,_,_)) -> error "lam_and_popl"
| (n, q) -> poprec (n-1, prod_and_pop_named q)
in
poprec (n,(env,t,l,[]))
(* [dep_option] indicates wether the inversion lemma is dependent or not.
If it is dependent and I is of the form (x_bar:T_bar)(I t_bar) then
the stated goal will be (x_bar:T_bar)(H:(I t_bar))(P t_bar H)
where P:(x_bar:T_bar)(H:(I t_bar))[sort] .
The generalisation of such a goal at the moment of the dependent case should
be easy
If it is non dependent, then if [I]=(I t_bar) and (x_bar:T_bar) are thte
variables occurring in [I], then the stated goal will be:
(x_bar:T_bar)(I t_bar)->(P x_bar)
where P: P:(x_bar:T_bar)(H:(I t_bar)->[sort]
*)
let compute_first_inversion_scheme sign i sort dep_option =
let (ity,largs) = find_mrectype empty_evd i in
let ar = mind_arity ity in
(* let ar = nf_betadeltaiota empty_evd (mind_arity ity) in *)
let fv = global_vars i in
let thin_sign = thin_hyps_to_term (sign,i) in
if not(same_members fv (ids_of_sign thin_sign)) then
errorlabstrm "lemma_inversion"
[< 'sTR"Cannot compute lemma inversion when there are" ; 'sPC ;
'sTR"free variables in the types of an inductive" ; 'sPC ;
'sTR"which are not free in its instance" >];
let p = next_ident_away (id_of_string "P") (ids_of_sign sign) in
if dep_option then
let (pty,goal) =
let (env,_,_) = push_and_liftl (nb_prod ar) [] ar [] in
let h = next_ident_away (id_of_string "P") (ids_of_sign sign) in
let (env1,_)= push_and_lift (Name h, (build_app ity env)) env [] in
let (_,pty,_) = prod_and_popl_named (List.length env1) env1 sort [] in
let pHead= applist(VAR p, largs@[Rel 1])
in (pty, Environ.prod_name(Name h,i,pHead))
in
(prepend_sign thin_sign
(add_sign (p,nf_betadeltaiota empty_evd pty) nil_sign),
goal)
else
let local_sign = get_local_sign thin_sign in
let pHead=
applist(VAR p,
List.rev(List.map (fun id -> VAR id) (ids_of_sign local_sign)))in
let (pty,goal) =
(it_sign (fun b id ty -> mkNamedProd id ty b)
sort local_sign, mkArrow i pHead)
in
let npty = nf_betadeltaiota empty_evd pty in
let lid = global_vars npty in
let maxprefix =
if lid=[] then nil_sign else snd (max_prefix_sign lid thin_sign)
in
(prepend_sign local_sign (add_sign (p,npty) maxprefix), goal)
(* [inversion_scheme sign I]
Given a local signature, [sign], and an instance of an inductive
relation, [I], inversion_scheme will prove the associated inversion
scheme on sort [sort]. Depending on the value of [dep_option] it will
build a dependent lemma or a non-dependent one *)
let inversion_scheme sign i sort dep_option inv_op =
let (i,sign) = add_prods_sign empty_evd (i,sign) in
let sign = csign_of_tsign sign in
let (invSign,invGoal) =
compute_first_inversion_scheme sign i sort dep_option in
let invSign = castify_sign empty_evd invSign in
if (not((subset (global_vars invGoal) (ids_of_sign invSign)))) then
errorlabstrm "lemma_inversion"
[< 'sTR"Computed inversion goal was not closed in initial signature" >];
let invGoalj = fexecute empty_evd invSign invGoal in
let pfs =
mk_pftreestate
(mkGOAL (mt_ctxt Spset.empty) invSign (j_val_cast invGoalj)) in
let pfs =
solve_pftreestate (tclTHEN intro
(onLastHyp (comp inv_op outSOME))) pfs in
let pf = proof_of_pftreestate pfs in
let (pfterm,meta_types) = Refiner.extract_open_proof pf.goal.hyps pf in
let invSign =
sign_it
(fun id ty sign ->
if mem_sign (initial_sign()) id then sign
else add_sign (id,ty) sign)
invSign
nil_sign
in
let (invSign,mvb) =
List.fold_left
(fun (sign,mvb) (mv,mvty) ->
let h = next_ident_away (id_of_string "H") (ids_of_sign sign) in
(add_sign (h,mvty) sign,
(mv,((VAR h):constr))::mvb))
(csign_of_tsign invSign,[])
meta_types
in
let invProof =
it_sign (fun b id ty -> mkNamedLambda id ty b)
(strong (whd_meta mvb) pfterm) invSign
in
invProof
open Discharge
open Constrtypes
let add_inversion_lemma name sign i sort dep_option inv_op =
let invProof = inversion_scheme sign i sort dep_option inv_op in
machine_constant_verbose (initial_assumptions())
((name,false,NeverDischarge),invProof)
open Pfedit
(* inv_op = Inv (derives de complete inv. lemma)
* inv_op = InvNoThining (derives de semi inversion lemma) *)
let inversion_lemma_from_goal n na id sort dep_option inv_op =
let pts = get_pftreestate() in
let pf = proof_of_pftreestate pts in
let gll,_ = frontier pf in
let gl = List.nth gll (n-1) in
add_inversion_lemma na gl.hyps (snd(lookup_sign id gl.hyps)).body
sort dep_option inv_op
let inversion_clear = inv false (Some true) None
open Vernacinterp
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeInversionLemmaFromHyp",
fun [VARG_NUMBER n;
VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_IDENTIFIER id] ->
fun () ->
inversion_lemma_from_goal n na id mkProp
false (inversion_clear false))
let no_inductive_inconstr ass constr =
[< 'sTR "Cannot recognize an inductive predicate in "; term0 ass constr;
'sTR "."; 'sPC; 'sTR "If there is one, may be the structure of the arity";
'sPC; 'STR "or of the type of constructors"; 'sPC;
'sTR "is hidden by constant definitions." >]
let add_inversion_lemma_exn na constr sort bool tac =
try
(add_inversion_lemma na (initial_sign()) constr sort bool tac)
with
| Induc ->
errorlabstrm "add_inversion_lemma" (no_inductive_inconstr
(gLOB (initial_sign())) constr)
| UserError ("abstract_list_all",_) ->
no_generalisation()
| UserError ("Case analysis",s) ->
errorlabstrm "Inv needs Nodep Prop Set" s
| UserError ("mind_specif_of_mind",_) ->
errorlabstrm "mind_specif_of_mind"
(no_inductive_inconstr (gLOB (initial_sign())) constr)
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeInversionLemma",
fun [VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_COMMAND com;
VARG_COMMAND sort] ->
fun () ->
add_inversion_lemma_exn na
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) com)
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) sort)
false (inversion_clear false))
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeSemiInversionLemmaFromHyp",
fun [VARG_NUMBER n;
VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_IDENTIFIER id] ->
fun () ->
inversion_lemma_from_goal n na id mkProp false
(inversion_clear false))
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeSemiInversionLemma",
fun [VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_COMMAND com;
VARG_COMMAND sort] ->
fun () ->
add_inversion_lemma_exn na
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) com)
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) sort)
false (inv false (Some false) None false))
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeDependentInversionLemma",
fun [VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_COMMAND com;
VARG_COMMAND sort] ->
fun () ->
add_inversion_lemma_exn na
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) com)
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) sort)
true (inversion_clear true))
let _ =
vinterp_add
("MakeDependentSemiInversionLemma",
fun [VARG_IDENTIFIER na;
VARG_COMMAND com;
VARG_COMMAND sort] ->
fun () ->
add_inversion_lemma_exn na
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) com)
(constr_of_com empty_evd (initial_sign()) sort)
true (inversion_clear true))
(* ================================= *)
(* Applying a given inversion lemma *)
(* ================================= *)
let lemInv id c gls =
try
let (wc,kONT) = startWalk gls in
let clause = mk_clenv_type_of wc c in
let clause = clenv_constrain_with_bindings [(ABS (-1),VAR id)] clause in
res_pf kONT clause gls
with
| Not_found ->
errorlabstrm "LemInv" (not_found_message [id])
| UserError (a,b) ->
errorlabstrm "LemInv"
[< 'sTR "Cannot refine current goal with the lemma ";
term0 (gLOB (initial_sign())) c >]
let useInversionLemma =
let gentac =
hide_tactic "UseInversionLemma"
(fun [IDENTIFIER id;COMMAND com] gls ->
lemInv id (pf_constr_of_com gls com) gls)
(*fun sigma gl (_,[IDENTIFIER id;COMMAND com]) ->
[< 'sTR"UseInv" ; 'sPC ; print_id id ; 'sPC ; pr_com sigma gl com >]*)
in
fun id com -> gentac [IDENTIFIER id;COMMAND com]
let lemInvIn id c ids gls =
let intros_replace_ids gls =
let nb_of_new_hyp = nb_prod (pf_concl gls) - List.length ids in
if nb_of_new_hyp < 1 then
introsReplacing ids gls
else
(tclTHEN (tclDO nb_of_new_hyp intro) (introsReplacing ids)) gls
in
try
((tclTHEN (tclTHEN (bring_hyps (List.map inSOME ids))
(lemInv id c))
(intros_replace_ids)) gls)
with Not_found -> errorlabstrm "LemInvIn" (not_found_message ids)
| UserError(a,b) -> errorlabstrm "LemInvIn" b
let useInversionLemmaIn =
let gentac = hide_tactic "UseInversionLemmaIn"
(fun ((IDENTIFIER id)::(COMMAND com)::hl) gls ->
lemInvIn id (pf_constr_of_com gls com)
(List.map (fun (IDENTIFIER id) -> id) hl) gls)
in
fun id com hl ->
gentac ((IDENTIFIER id)::(COMMAND com)
::(List.map (fun id -> (IDENTIFIER id)) hl))
|